SpunkArt
Home and local services · Atlanta

How to compare three contractor quotes in Atlanta

The lowest number on a quote is not always the lowest cost. Three quotes only help you when they describe the same job. This guide shows how to make them match and then compare them fairly.

Please note: This page is general information only. Check the details for your own situation before you rely on it.

Why three quotes and not one

One quote tells you what one company wants to charge. Two quotes tell you that prices differ. Three quotes start to show you a range, and they often reveal a step that one contractor included and another forgot. In a large metro area such as Atlanta you can usually find several firms willing to visit, so collecting three is realistic for most outdoor and repair jobs.

Give every contractor the same written description of the job. If you describe a fence to one company as “about 120 feet” and to another as “the back yard”, the quotes will not line up no matter how careful you are later.

Step by step: normalise the quotes

  1. Copy each quote into one table. One row per item: materials, labour, removal of the old work, permit, clean-up, warranty.
  2. Mark every blank. A blank means “not included” until the contractor tells you otherwise in writing.
  3. Ask about each blank. Phone or email and ask for a price for the missing item. Write the answer next to the quote.
  4. Add the missing items to the total. Now every quote covers the same job.
  5. Divide by the quantity. A price per linear foot, per square foot or per fixture lets you compare jobs of slightly different size.

Worked example: a 120-foot wood fence

These figures are invented for the example. Suppose you want to replace 120 linear feet of fence and you receive three quotes.

ItemQuote AQuote BQuote C
Quoted total$5,400$4,800$6,300
Old fence removalIncludedNot included: $450 extraIncluded
PermitNot included: $150 extraNot included: $150 extraIncluded
Warranty on labour1 yearNone stated3 years
Adjusted total$5,550$5,400$6,300
Per linear foot$46.25$45.00$52.50
price per foot = adjusted total ÷ 120

Quote B looked $600 cheaper than Quote A. After you add removal and the permit, the gap shrinks to $150, and Quote B gives no warranty. Quote C costs $7.50 more per foot, so it must justify that with the longer warranty or better materials, such as heavier posts. That is now a question you can ask directly.

What the price does not show

  • Material grade. “Pressure-treated pine” and “cedar” are different products. Ask for the exact material on paper.
  • Schedule. A quote that starts in two weeks may be worth more to you than one that starts in three months.
  • Payment terms. A large deposit raises your risk. See the payment guide linked below.
  • Who does the work. Ask whether the firm uses its own crew or subcontractors.

Common mistakes

  • Picking the lowest total before you fill the blanks.
  • Accepting a verbal “we’ll take care of that” for an item that is missing from the paper.
  • Comparing a quote for a 100-foot fence with one for a 130-foot fence without dividing by length.
  • Throwing out the highest quote without asking why it is high. Sometimes it is the only honest one.

FAQ

Is it rude to tell a contractor I am getting other quotes?

No. Most contractors expect it. Saying so politely often makes the quote more complete, because the firm knows you will read it closely.

Should I share one contractor’s price with another?

You can ask a contractor to explain why their price differs, but avoid using one quote only to pressure another. Ask about scope, not just the number.

What if two quotes are very far apart?

A large gap usually means the two firms understood the job differently. Go back to both with the same written description and ask them to confirm what they included.