SpunkArt
Renting and buying a home · New York

Co-op or condo? How the two apartment types differ in New York

Many apartments for sale in New York City are co-ops or condos. They can look identical from inside, but you own something quite different in each, and the buying process differs too. This guide explains the differences in general terms.

Please note: This page is general education, not financial, tax or investment advice. Check your own numbers and talk to a qualified professional before you decide.

What you actually own

In a condominium, you own your unit as real property, plus a share of the common areas such as the lobby and roof. You receive a deed, and the unit has its own property tax bill.

In a housing cooperative, a corporation owns the whole building. You buy shares in that corporation, and the shares come with a proprietary lease that gives you the right to live in a specific apartment. You are a shareholder and a tenant of the corporation at the same time.

Side by side

TopicCo-opCondo
OwnershipShares plus a proprietary leaseDeeded unit plus common-area share
Monthly chargeMaintenance: covers building costs, and usually the building’s property tax and any building mortgageCommon charges for building costs; property tax billed separately
Buyer approvalBoard reviews an application and usually interviews the buyer; it can rejectBoard often has a right of first refusal, which is rarely a full review
FinancingShare loan; the board may set its own minimum down payment and finance rulesStandard mortgage on the unit
SublettingOften limited by house rulesUsually more flexible
SellingNext buyer also needs board approval; some co-ops charge a transfer fee, often called a flip taxGenerally simpler

The co-op board package

A co-op purchase typically includes a board package: tax returns, bank and investment statements, employment letters, reference letters and a financial summary. Boards look at debt-to-income and at how much money you will have left after closing. Ask the building, through the listing agent, for its specific requirements early, because they shape how much cash you need.

Comparing monthly costs

Labelled example, not market figures. Both loans are at 6.5% for 30 years.

  • Co-op: price $400,000, 25% down, loan $300,000. Loan payment $1,896.20 + maintenance $1,600 = $3,496.20 per month.
  • Condo: price $450,000, 20% down, loan $360,000. Loan payment $2,275.44 + common charges $700 + property tax $600 = $3,575.44 per month.

The co-op costs less to buy but needs a larger share down, and its maintenance is higher because it includes tax. Always compare the full monthly total. Figures rounded to the cent.

Questions to ask about any building

  1. Is there an underlying mortgage on the building, and when does it mature? (co-ops)
  2. Have there been assessments in recent years, or are any planned?
  3. How healthy is the reserve fund?
  4. Are there major projects, such as facade or elevator work, coming up?
  5. What are the rules on pets, renovations, subletting and pied-à-terre use?

Read the offering plan, recent financial statements and board minutes. Buyers in New York commonly use a real estate attorney to review these documents.

Common mistakes

  • Comparing a co-op’s maintenance with a condo’s common charges without adding the condo’s tax bill.
  • Making an offer before you know the board’s financial rules.
  • Assuming you can rent the apartment out later.

Questions

Why are co-ops often priced lower?

Board approval, financing rules and sublet limits make them less flexible, which narrows the pool of buyers.

Must a co-op board explain a rejection?

Rules differ by place and change over time. Ask an attorney about current local rules, including fair housing protections.