Should you own a car in New York? A cost comparison
New York has one of the densest transit networks in the country, and many residents live without a car. Whether you should depends on where you live, how you travel and what a car really costs you each month. This guide sets out a method for doing the sums with your own numbers.
List every cost of owning, not just the payment
People often compare a transit pass with a car loan payment and stop there. A fair comparison counts everything a car costs to keep, even when the car sits still.
| Cost | Fixed or per mile | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Loan or lease payment | Fixed | If you own it outright, count depreciation instead |
| Insurance | Fixed | Get real quotes for your address |
| Parking | Fixed | A garage space, or the time cost of street parking |
| Fuel | Per mile | Miles ÷ mpg × price |
| Maintenance and tyres | Mostly per mile | Set aside a monthly amount |
| Registration, inspection, tolls, tickets | Mixed | Spread yearly costs over 12 months |
List the cost of the alternative
Living car-free still costs money. Add your transit fares and any rides, car-share hours, rentals for weekend trips and delivery charges you would not pay with a car.
Worked comparison
Example with invented round numbers. These figures are for showing the method only. They are not New York prices; use your own quotes.
- Car: payment $450 + insurance $210 + parking $400 + fuel $90 + maintenance fund $60 = $1,210 per month
- Car-free: transit $132 + rentals and rides $150 = $282 per month
- Difference: 1,210 − 282 = $928 per month, or 928 × 12 = $11,136 per year
Now flip the question: how many rentals or rides could you take before car-free costs as much as owning? In this example, the extra $928 per month buys a great deal of occasional car use. Your own figures may tell a very different story, for example if you have free parking or commute to a place transit does not reach.
Things the sums leave out
- Time. Count door-to-door time for your regular trips both ways, including the search for parking.
- Reliability. A late train and a traffic jam both cost time; which happens more on your routes?
- Accessibility. Mobility needs, small children or heavy equipment can make a car essential.
- Trips outside the city. Regular weekend trips favour owning; rare ones favour renting.
- Street parking rules. Moving a car for street cleaning takes time each week. Check the city’s official parking rules for your block.
If you keep a car in a dense city
Cars that are driven little have their own care needs. Batteries drain when a car sits for weeks, so start and drive it regularly or use a battery maintainer if you have power access. Tyres can develop flat spots and lose pressure. Brake discs can rust on the surface. Your owner’s manual may list a time-based service interval for low-mileage use, such as changing oil after a set number of months even if you drove few miles.
Common mistakes
- Forgetting insurance and parking, which can be larger than fuel.
- Comparing a single month instead of a full year with its holidays and trips.
- Ignoring the money tied up in the car, which you could otherwise save.
Is leasing cheaper for a city driver?
A lease limits yearly miles, which can suit someone who drives little. Compare total cost over the lease, including fees at the end, with buying and selling a car over the same years.
What about car-share services?
They can fill the gap between transit and owning. Price out your real pattern of trips, since hourly costs add up on long days.