SpunkArt
Car care · New York

Should you own a car in New York? A cost comparison

New York has one of the densest transit networks in the country, and many residents live without a car. Whether you should depends on where you live, how you travel and what a car really costs you each month. This guide sets out a method for doing the sums with your own numbers.

List every cost of owning, not just the payment

People often compare a transit pass with a car loan payment and stop there. A fair comparison counts everything a car costs to keep, even when the car sits still.

CostFixed or per mileNotes
Loan or lease paymentFixedIf you own it outright, count depreciation instead
InsuranceFixedGet real quotes for your address
ParkingFixedA garage space, or the time cost of street parking
FuelPer mileMiles ÷ mpg × price
Maintenance and tyresMostly per mileSet aside a monthly amount
Registration, inspection, tolls, ticketsMixedSpread yearly costs over 12 months

List the cost of the alternative

Living car-free still costs money. Add your transit fares and any rides, car-share hours, rentals for weekend trips and delivery charges you would not pay with a car.

Worked comparison

Example with invented round numbers. These figures are for showing the method only. They are not New York prices; use your own quotes.

  • Car: payment $450 + insurance $210 + parking $400 + fuel $90 + maintenance fund $60 = $1,210 per month
  • Car-free: transit $132 + rentals and rides $150 = $282 per month
  • Difference: 1,210 − 282 = $928 per month, or 928 × 12 = $11,136 per year

Now flip the question: how many rentals or rides could you take before car-free costs as much as owning? In this example, the extra $928 per month buys a great deal of occasional car use. Your own figures may tell a very different story, for example if you have free parking or commute to a place transit does not reach.

Things the sums leave out

  • Time. Count door-to-door time for your regular trips both ways, including the search for parking.
  • Reliability. A late train and a traffic jam both cost time; which happens more on your routes?
  • Accessibility. Mobility needs, small children or heavy equipment can make a car essential.
  • Trips outside the city. Regular weekend trips favour owning; rare ones favour renting.
  • Street parking rules. Moving a car for street cleaning takes time each week. Check the city’s official parking rules for your block.

If you keep a car in a dense city

Cars that are driven little have their own care needs. Batteries drain when a car sits for weeks, so start and drive it regularly or use a battery maintainer if you have power access. Tyres can develop flat spots and lose pressure. Brake discs can rust on the surface. Your owner’s manual may list a time-based service interval for low-mileage use, such as changing oil after a set number of months even if you drove few miles.

Common mistakes

  • Forgetting insurance and parking, which can be larger than fuel.
  • Comparing a single month instead of a full year with its holidays and trips.
  • Ignoring the money tied up in the car, which you could otherwise save.
Is leasing cheaper for a city driver?

A lease limits yearly miles, which can suit someone who drives little. Compare total cost over the lease, including fees at the end, with buying and selling a car over the same years.

What about car-share services?

They can fill the gap between transit and owning. Price out your real pattern of trips, since hourly costs add up on long days.