SpunkArt
Personal finance · Phoenix

Paying down debt: avalanche or snowball?

Two popular plans for paying off several debts are the avalanche and the snowball. Both work. This Phoenix guide runs the same three debts through each method so you can see what the choice really costs.

Please note: This page is general education, not financial, tax or investment advice. Check your own numbers and talk to a qualified professional before you decide.

The two methods in one line each

  • Avalanche: pay the minimum on every debt, then send all extra money to the debt with the highest interest rate.
  • Snowball: pay the minimum on every debt, then send all extra money to the debt with the smallest balance.

When one debt is gone, its minimum payment rolls over to the next target. That rollover is the “snowball” that gives the second method its name, and both plans use it.

The example debts

Suppose a household has these three debts and can put $600 per month toward them in total. Interest is charged monthly at the yearly rate divided by 12.

DebtBalanceYearly rateMinimum payment
Store card$90015%$35
Credit card$4,20024%$110
Car loan$7,5007%$220

The minimums add up to $365, so $235 is left over each month for the target debt.

What happens month by month

I ran both plans in a short script, applying interest first and then payments each month. Results are rounded to the cent.

SnowballAvalanche
Order of attackstore card, credit card, car loancredit card, store card, car loan
First debt clearedmonth 4month 15
Second debt clearedmonth 16month 16
All debt clearedmonth 24month 24
Total interest paid$1,564.15$1,482.04

The avalanche saves $82.11 in this example. The snowball gives a visible win in month 4 instead of month 15. Both finish in the same month here, because the large, low-rate car loan is last either way.

How to choose

Mathematically, the avalanche always pays the same or less interest. The gap grows when the high-rate debt is also large and the small debts carry low rates. The snowball costs a little more but can keep you going, and a plan you stick to beats a plan you abandon.

A practical middle path: if two debts have similar rates, clear the smaller one first. If one rate is far higher than the rest, go after it first.

Steps to start this week

  1. List every debt with its balance, rate and minimum payment, using the latest statements.
  2. Decide the fixed monthly amount you can commit, including minimums.
  3. Sort the list by rate (avalanche) or by balance (snowball).
  4. Set every minimum to pay automatically so nothing goes late.
  5. Send the extra amount to the top of the list on the same day each month.
  6. When a debt reaches zero, move its whole payment to the next one. Do not let it drift back into spending.

Summer electricity bills for cooling can squeeze the budget in a hot climate. If your payment amount must vary by season, set the plan around your leanest month so you do not miss a payment in July.

Common mistakes

  • Continuing to add new charges to a card you are paying off.
  • Ignoring the rollover and spending a freed-up minimum payment.
  • Draining every dollar of savings into debt, then borrowing again at the next surprise bill.

Questions

Does a balance transfer help?

It can, if the transfer fee and the rate after the promotion still beat your current cost and you can clear the balance before the promotion ends. Read the terms carefully.

Where can I get free help?

Nonprofit credit counselling agencies can review a budget with you. The CFPB publishes guidance on choosing one and on avoiding debt relief scams.