SpunkArt
Smart shopping · Charlotte

How stacked discounts really work

When a store takes 20% off and then a coupon takes another 10% off, the total saving is 28%, not 30%. This guide for Charlotte shoppers explains why, and shows how to work out the real price before you reach the register.

The short answer

The second discount does not apply to the original price. It applies to the price that is left after the first discount. So you multiply what remains, not add what comes off.

final price = original × (1 − d1) × (1 − d2)
total discount = 1 − (1 − d1) × (1 − d2)

Worked example: 20% then 10%

Example. A jacket has a ticket price of $100. The rack sign says 20% off, and you have a coupon for an extra 10% off.

  1. After 20% off you pay 80% of the price: 100 × 0.80 = $80.
  2. The coupon takes 10% off $80, not off $100: 80 × 0.90 = $72.
  3. You save $28 on a $100 item. That is 28%.

Check: 1 − (0.80 × 0.90) = 1 − 0.72 = 0.28.

Shoppers lose track of this because ads often place the two numbers side by side. “Take an extra 10% off sale prices” is honest wording, but it is easy to read as 30% off.

Does the order matter?

For two percentage discounts, no. Multiplication gives the same result in any order, so 10% then 20% also ends at $72. Order does matter when one discount is a fixed dollar amount.

Example with a dollar coupon. A $60 pair of shoes is 25% off, and you also have a $10-off coupon.

  • Percentage first: 60 × 0.75 = $45, then $45 − $10 = $35.
  • Dollar coupon first: $60 − $10 = $50, then 50 × 0.75 = $37.50.

Taking the percentage first saves you $2.50 more. The store’s register decides the order, and it often takes the percentage first, but the coupon terms can say otherwise.

A quick reference table

Total discount for common pairs, computed as 1 − (1 − d1)(1 − d2):

FirstSecondLooks likeActually
20%10%30%28%
25%15%40%36.25%
40%20%60%52%
50%50%100%75%

The last row is the clearest proof. Half off and then half off again does not make an item free. It leaves a quarter of the price.

Read the coupon terms before you plan

  • “Cannot be combined with other offers.” Only one discount applies. Pick the larger one.
  • “Excludes sale items.” The coupon will not stack on a rack discount at all.
  • Minimum spend. A coupon that needs a minimum purchase may check the total before or after other discounts. The terms usually say which.
  • Tax. Sales tax is normally charged on the discounted price, so a bigger discount also cuts the tax slightly.

Common mistakes

  • Adding the percentages and expecting a lower total than the register shows.
  • Assuming a third discount, such as a loyalty reward, follows the same rules as the first two.
  • Buying something extra only to reach a minimum spend, which can cost more than the coupon saves.

Questions

Is “an extra 10% off” misleading?

Not by itself. It means 10% off the already reduced price. The confusion comes from adding the numbers in your head.

How do I check a receipt quickly?

Multiply the ticket price by each “what you pay” fraction in turn (0.8, then 0.9, and so on). Compare the result to the line on the receipt.