SpunkArt
Eating out · Chicago

Chicago pizza: deep-dish or tavern-style thin crust?

Visitors often expect every Chicago pizza to be deep-dish. Many locals eat thin, crisp tavern-style pizza cut into squares just as often. This guide explains both styles so you can order the one that fits your evening.

Two pizzas, one city

Chicago has two well-known pizza traditions, and they are almost opposites. Deep-dish is baked in a tall, round pan with high sides. Tavern-style is a very thin, crisp crust, cut into small squares instead of wedges. Neither is the “real” one. They suit different situations.

FeatureDeep-dishTavern-style thin crust
CrustThick walls, pressed up the sides of a panThin and cracker-crisp to the edge
Layer orderCheese at the bottom, fillings, then chunky tomato sauce on topSauce, then cheese and toppings, like most pizzas
How it is cutWedges, eaten with a knife and forkSmall squares, often called a party cut
Bake timeLong, because the pan is full and deepShort
Good forA sit-down meal where the pizza is the eventSharing, snacking, mixed groups, kids

Why the deep-dish wait is longer

A deep-dish pie holds a thick layer of cheese and sauce. Heat needs time to reach the centre, so it bakes for much longer than a thin pizza. Many places tell you the wait when you order. Some let you place the pizza order while you wait for a table, so it comes out sooner after you sit down.

Plan for it. If you are hungry, order a salad or a starter to share. If you have a show or a train to catch, choose thin crust or ask the server how long the pie takes before you commit.

How much to order

Deep-dish is heavy. A slice that looks small on the plate is often filling, so groups tend to over-order. A reasonable approach:

  1. Count the people and decide if the pizza is the whole meal or one part of it.
  2. Ask the server how many people one size usually feeds. They answer this question all day.
  3. Order one size smaller than your first instinct for deep-dish. You can add a thin-crust pie later; it arrives fast.
  4. Take leftovers home. Deep-dish reheats well in an oven, where the crust crisps again, and less well in a microwave.

Eating each style

Deep-dish

Let it rest for a few minutes. The cheese and sauce are very hot straight out of the oven, and the slice holds together better after a short wait. Use a fork and knife; picking it up by hand usually ends with the filling sliding out.

Tavern-style

Eat it with your hands. The squares mean everyone takes as much as they want. The middle pieces have no crust edge, and the corner pieces have the most crunch, so people often have a favourite position.

Common mistakes

  • Ordering deep-dish on an empty stomach with no starter, then waiting a long time.
  • Ordering one large deep-dish per two people. That is usually far too much food.
  • Assuming thin crust is a lesser option. In Chicago it is a tradition of its own.
  • Forgetting to ask about allergens: deep-dish crusts and sauces vary by kitchen, so ask if you avoid dairy, wheat or certain oils.

When the bill comes, use the tip and split calculator to divide it.

Questions

Is stuffed pizza the same as deep-dish?

No. Stuffed pizza is a related style with an extra thin layer of dough above the filling and the sauce on top of that. It is also deep and slow to bake.

Can I order half deep-dish and half thin?

Not on one pie, because they bake in different pans. Order one of each instead.